While the series heavily explores Johns relationship with his children, it does not dive much into Johns relationship with his own parents. James has two siblings: Claire, who shares the screen in 1883, and Jacob, who makes his appearance in 1923. Now, Kevin Costner is reflecting on Johns perspective on the bombshell and John and Jamies relationship. However, the show has not mentioned the exact reason for her death. Garrett is an ex-con who killed his wife and Jamie's mother, a woman suffering from a drug addiction, when Jamie was a child, as Looper explains. Evelyn appears in the. One fan elaborated: I dont think she was related to them in any way, I just think because it was a small town they all knew each other and she was a friend of the family. James has two siblings: Claire, who shares the screen in 1883, and Jacob, who makes his appearance in 1923. As a result, she might have become withdrawn from the rest of her family. In the case of the time that I play him, the character is both good and goes very bad and desperately wants to go back to come good, said Lucas in an interview. Perhaps, that had to do with Jamie going above and criminally beyond to correct his course. John Dutton III is a main character on Yellowstone. As a result, she might have become withdrawn from the rest of her family. Though she did not succumb immediately, Evelyn died within a few hours.[1]. Distant son Jamie Dutton was devastated to discover his true origins in the latest season of Yellowstone. Jamie Dutton is the name of the Dutton patriarch that first claimed the land and founded the Yellowstone ranch. He may not have wanted Jamie even if he was his estranged sisters son. Evelyn may have convinced John to take Jamie in because he is family and continues to care for him to honor his wife. He has an unnamed baby after a relationship with Christina. There is no question why Jamie feels like such an outsider. James's wife Margaret is portrayed by his real-live love, Faith Hill. (@wesbentleyfanpage) The wife of Jacob Dutton, Cara (Helen Mirren) was the matriarch of the Dutton family in 1923. Therefore, she allows Jamie to meet his son for the first time. NY 10036. He is the former Livestock Commissioner for the state of Montana and one of the most respected, powerful members of the communities from Bozeman to Livingston. The .css-k807px{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;text-decoration-thickness:0.0625rem;text-decoration-color:brandColorSenary;text-underline-offset:0.25rem;color:#006603;-webkit-transition:background .4s ease-in-out,color .4s ease-in-out;transition:background .4s ease-in-out,color .4s ease-in-out;background:linear-gradient(to bottom,#e6f4e1 0,#e6f4e1 100%);-webkit-background-position:0 100%;background-position:0 100%;background-repeat:repeat-x;-webkit-background-size:0 0;background-size:0 0;}.css-k807px:hover{color:#29511A;text-decoration-color:border-link-body-hover;-webkit-background-size:0.625rem 3.125rem;background-size:0.625rem 3.125rem;}Yellowstone universe is constantly evolving. Its like a part of her soul just left when her mother died. He buried Evelyn on the ranch. We don't share land down here.John Dutton to the Chinese tourists on his property. John Dutton Sr. (James Badge Dale) is the namesake of Yellowstone's John Dutton and is the second child of James and Margaret. They'll tell you that the lands only hope is for them to be it's steward. John Dutton adopted Jamie even though he despises Jamies birth father. Emma (Marley Shelton) was the wife of John Dutton Sr. and mother of Jack Dutton in 1923. Trending SR Exclusives Star Wars Marvel DC Star Trek The Last of Us The Mandalorian. One perceptive viewer realised Jamies real mother was probably connected to the Dutton ranch in some way, thanks to his candid conversation with his adoptive father, John. The show is trying pretty hard to tie in both spin-off shows and this could be another connection to 1883. Actor Kelly Reilly discussed the impact that Evelyns death had on her character, Beth. Jamie went off to do just that when his father talked him down. Like a contented Hallmark movie character, Britt happily lives in the same city she grew up in. John also told Jamie that he begged Jamies birth mother not to marry Garrett Randall because John knew what kind of man Garrett was. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. He made that connection official when he married Beth. With Jamies mind in a tailspin, and the fate of the rest of the family on tenterhooks after the season finale, fans are anticipating even more exhilarating twists and turns for season four. The ugly truth is they want the land, and if they get it, it will never look like our land again. She has never been able to get past that. This complete list includes 1883 and 1923. Strong theory and great insight. Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. After some time, Garrett is able to bond with his son, expressing that he is proud of him. He has even strayed away from the family, searching for his birth father, Garrett Randall (Will Patton), who tries to convince him to turn against the Duttons. Elsa (Isabel May), daughter of James and Margaret, serves as the narrator in both 1883 and 1923. John was married to Evelyn Dutton (Gretchen Mol), . Flashbacks have revealed that Evelyn was not the gentlest mother, after all, and the depth of her bond with Jamie is as yet unclear. Jamies Parentage Explained, LPBW: Zach & Toris Family Excited For Christmas 2023! Being an ambitious lawyer with political aspirations may impress many families, as long as it's not the Duttons on "Yellowstone." Phyllis was not watching her baby as she was busy hooking up with another man. Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley) is adopted. As with Johns wife, Evelyn, who only appears a handful of times, Johns relationship with arguably one of the most important women in his life remains unexplored. (Like, does Jamie actually descend from Spencer's line and John has tried to screw him out of a rightful inheritance? She was heartbroken after Peter passed away and never tried to have children again. Jamies father struggled to make ends meet, and his mother struggled with a drug addict. Both Kayce and Beth witnessed the death of their mother, but Beth carries the guilt of blaming herself for what happened. John is the only character to cross over between 1883 and 1923. Will Jamie do that now? Christina is aware that Jamie has cut the Duttons out of his life and is making his own decisions now. It doesn't mean I didnt feel different, but I made a conscious effort to give him the same love and attention that his brother and sister did, and that had to do with my wife. Advertisement Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Yellowstone's latest episode revealed what happened between Beth Dutton and her brother Jamie. Yellowstone is an American neo-Western drama television series created by Taylor Sheridan and John Linson that premiered on June 20, 2018, on Paramount Network.The series stars Kevin Costner, Luke Grimes, Kelly Reilly, Wes Bentley, Cole Hauser, Kelsey Asbille, and Gil Birmingham.The series follows the conflicts along the shared borders of the Yellowstone Ranch, a large cattle ranch, the Broken . Rip goes on to romance John's daughter Beth Dutton, played by British actress, 45 . Why Did John Dutton Adopt Jamie? Interestingly, Jamie is on the precipice of learning this for himself. I am sure that John believes that in his heart, but his eyes should tell him another story. Adopted son of John and Evelyn, Jamie (Wes Bentley) was raised as one of their own. However, before Jamies history is finally told in full, fans are holding out hope for the survival of the rest of the family after a horrific series of attacks in the final moments of this years finale. Yellowstone season 4: Will Rip Wheeler kill Angela Blue Thunder? John Dutton IV (adoptive nephew) Appears in Yellowstone No. Redditor Luvsplants123 posted: So who do you think Jamie's real mother is? 0. For his part, Jamie seemed somewhat swayed by Johns impassioned speech. Jamie's Parentage Explained December 11, 2022 hnm102 In season three it came as a shocker that Jamie Dutton was adopted and John was not his biological father. Jamie's father struggled to make ends meet, and his mother struggled with a drug addict. She was raised on the Broken Rock Reservation and suffered a devastating accident in season 5 that resulted in the loss of her baby. Furthermore, John rarely speaks about his mother making it difficult for us to understand the personality and nature of Johns mother. Jamie has reasons for why he feels alienated by John, and I do not think either party is all-wrong in their opinion about the relationship. John withheld important information whether it was about Jamies mother being a Dutton, Evelyns sister, or whatever other reason Jamie has a privileged position as as an adopted son. Hes always moving all that stuff around.". ---- According to Kevin Costner, John Dutton feels as though there has been no difference in how he has treated Jamie versus the late Lee, Kayce, and Beth, at least when both parents were in the picture. John did warn Jamie that one more betrayal would mean being dead to him, and viewers will have to see if the adoption bombshell pushes Jamie over the edge in that regard. On the show, Dutton has been widowed for many years, as his wife died before the show's timeline began. She says no. She and John also adopted Jamie after his father killed his mother when he was young. John raised Jamie as his own but he is not his biological father. John Dutton clearly was close to Jamies birth mother well before Jamie was born. During some of the most pivotal moments of the latest season, Jamie unearthed his birth records to discover ranch owner John Dutton (Kevin Costner) is not his biological father. However, things go south when Jamie learns his father is behind the attacks on Beth, John and Kayce in season three. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. His intentions might have been there, but I do not think he has been as forgiving of Jamie as he has Kayce. Exactly, because of those comments by John, I had thought that perhaps his mother was Evelyn's sister. When Jamie confronted John, the latter filled his son in on most of the details surrounding the Yellowstone secret. Season 5 airing Sundays on Paramount Network beginning November 13th, 2022. Upon being released from jail, Garrett tells Jamie that he k*lled his mother to save Jamies life. John Dutton Sr., originally known as John Dutton, is a main character in 1883: A Yellowstone Origin Story. The main character in the story is named John Dutton. It took almost all of Episode 7 for the breadth of that revelation to wash over Jamie, who later confronted his father over the truth. Dutton was married to Evelyn, they had 4 kids together, 3 sons, one of which they adopted, and a daughter, and the two ran the ranch together prior to her death in 1997. He then. I feel like that is a whole lane that can have secrets in . Season 3 of Yellowstone continued with "Cowboys and Dreamers," which aired on Sunday, July 19. They knew Jamie's biological parents, with John having known his biological mother before she got married. Jamie was born as James Michael Randall to a couple named Garrett Randall and Phyllis Mary Randall, who had quite a rough marriage. They havent said yet, so right now its anyones guess. good points on the name/Rip counter. Jamie was then adopted by Evelyn Dutton and her husband John, where he came to live within a ranching family. We get to see this very pure young girl go through such a trauma, Reilly said in an interview. Sunday, 5th March 2023See today's front and back pages, download the newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive. John Dutton clearly was close to Jamie's birth mother well before Jamie was born," the Redditor explained. He owns one of the biggest cattle ranches of the United States. Beth ran for help while Kayce stayed with Evelyn. She seems to have been especially hard on Beth. Thank you for signing up to CinemaBlend. Other fans were quick to agree with this thought-out theory. Spoilers for Season 3, Episode 7 of Yellowstone entitled The Beating are discussed below. John reveals to Jamie in season three of Yellowstone that he knew his mother,Phyllis, before she married Garrett Randall. After tragedy, Elizabeth and Jack recite their vows to each other, and Elizabeth confides in Cara that she is pregnant. Similar to how Beth took in Carter and Rip had to deal with it, that is how Everlyn went about Jamie. In the second season finale, titled Sins of the Father, Johns father, John Dutton Jr (Dabney Coleman), plays a crucial role in underlining Johns fierce devotion to protecting his land. It is a lot for Jamie to process, but he eventually forms a relationship with his biological father. Theory: Jamie Dutton's birth mother is a Dutton John Dutton adopted Jamie even though he despises Jamie's birth father. When Jamie was looking at the court records, there were only a few months between her murder and Garrett's sentencing, so, maybe John didn't have a chance to "ship him off". She has been writing about entertainment for 5 years, and as you may suspect, still finds it as entertaining to do as when she began. After discovering he is not a Dutton by blood, Jamie sets out looking for answers. . James's brother, Jacob (Harrison Ford), is the leader of the Dutton family in 1923. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It would be quite the coincidence that Jamie would be given that name unless his mother was a Dutton and named Jamie after her most important Dutton ancestor. In Evelyns dying moments, she looked at Beth and said, She did this. Evelyn did have a soft spot for Kayce, as evidenced in a story John told earlier this season. That's when Jamie found out that the process for abortion would involve sterilization. Jamie Dutton is a lead character in the series, Yellowstone, where his campaign manager is mama to his baby. The Duttons adopted Jamie when he was only three months old and raised him as their own. "Yeah I knew him." Sketching a picture of his real father, John tells him, "When he married the woman who gave birth to you, we begged her not to do it . A few times when John is angry with Jamie he says something like, if I hadnt promised your mother or if I didnt love your mother so much Anyway guess we will fibd out (I hope)! Little is mentioned about Evelyn initially, however the events surrounding her death slowly come to light. Not Together Anymore? Who is John Dutton's parents? Bucked from her Horse and crushed due to Beth's hesitation. John and Evelyn Dutton adopted Jamie when he was just three months old. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. In season three, John reveals that he knew Jamie's mother Phyllis before she married Garrett Randall. Newsletter. In Paramount's Yellowstone, everyone knows that John Dutton III (Costner) is the head of his family. I think it's more likely that she is John's wife's sister. Reflecting on Johns feelings towards Jamie, Kevin Costner told Yellowstones Behind the Story: Its really in my mind that when my wife was alive, I treated him no different. I've thought along the lines that Jamie's mother was John's sister for some time now. I think it was Johns sister in law. "Love this narrative," replied u/haroldhecuba88. John Dutton III's brother died as an infant. Beth married longtime love Rip Wheeler in an unconventional ceremony in season 4. Jamie was born "Michael," son to an addict mother and violent father. At the end of Episode 4, Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley) finds out to his shock that Riggins' former cellmate in prison is Jamie's own biological father, Garrett Randall (Will Patton), with whom. Alex and Spencer are making their way to Montana to help Spencer's family. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Some believe that Phyllis was Evelyns sister, whereas others think that Phyllis could actually be a Dutton herself. Beth was nervous which caused her horse to spook the horse Evelyn was riding. Jack is a common nickname for John, so some fans speculate that he is actually John Jr., but that has not been revealed. There is something key in whomever their mothers are that is central to the resolution of the series. Save this link as we will be updating the information as more details are known and as new characters join the cast. He stepped down from his position at the request of Governor Lynelle Perry and his son, Kayce Dutton, was named the new Livestock Commissioner. One of the horses fell over and crushed her. As a result of being ostracized by his family, he has certainly acted out a time or two. John Dutton figures she has killed her brother. At the time Garrett is living on his own on a farm. The self-described "tornado" has a takes-no-prisoners approach to dealing with anyone who threatens her family, including her adopted brother Jamie. She passed away on March 30th, 1997. Jamie's father struggled to make ends meet, and his mother struggled with a drug addict. Beth gives Jamie three options: she would report both Jamie and Garrett to the police, she would tell Rip that Garrett tried to k*ll her or Jamie himself could k*ll Garrett. Question what you do and who you are. Yellowstone occasionally features flashbacks to the '90s, showing John Dutton and his wife Evelyn with their kids, Jamie, Beth and Kayce. But this just highlights what a lost soul Jamie is. If you are looking for answers about John Duttons mother in Yellowstone, here is everything we know in that regard! After John kicked the women out of the bunkhouse in the last episode, Teeter (Jen Landon) returns to plead her case and to point out that . This is America. After she wouldnt budge, he decided the only way out was to k*ll his father himself. Sister Wives: Critics Suspect That Meri Hired FAKE Guests To Promote Her Retreat! Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, My personal opinion is that John may be blinded in some ways concerning how he has genuinely treated Jamie. And because it was a favor for his wife, he was given better treatment than Rip when he was a kid. A level of bitterness and a resentment and he could've been the recipient of some of that. Hmmm this theory has been circulating on here for a while. At the time, he told her to keep it under wraps, but it's. In addition, the Duttons knew the Randalls, as they had known Phyllis before she married Garrett. Jamie even introduces him to his child and his childs mother, Christina. Does John descend from Spencer's line and Jamie from John I and then Jack's?). In real life, however, Costner is happily married to designer Christine Baumgartner.As per People, the actor was married to Cindy Silva until they . However, Evelyns death changed the character in a big way. How dare you destroy it.. She's a strong woman and mother of three (Elsa, Spencer, and John) who joins James in their perilous journey west, eventually settling in Montana. Help came too late and she died. Evelyn Dutton was the biological mother of Lee, Kayce, and Beth Dutton. Garrett killed his mother,Phyllis, in a fit of rage in 2005. Yellowstone season 4 spoilers: Kayce star teases more of the same. After coming home from work one day, Garrett was horrified to discover young Jamie crying and sucking on a crack pipe. When taking Garretts corpse to the train station to dispose of it, Beth catches Jamie in the acting and takes a photo of Jamie holding his dads corpse as evidence flor blackmail. Yellowstone viewers are unlikely to know unless a dream sequence around such a scenario were to get dramatized. It is likely that John Dutton adopted Jamie since he knew the Randall family and wanted to protect Jamie from any further harm. I do the very best I can for my children and if they want to tell me someday why I wasn't a great father, I guess I'll listen, but you know lots of luck to them. I like the theory. After doing that on Yellowstone, John said that Jamie could have killed himself instead of Sarah to right things. U/Matthmil hypothesized the story behind Jamie's mother is similar and that his birth mother is quite possibly a Dutton herself. Screen Rant. You don't see it on your way to work, in the fields, or on the mountain. Yellowstone season 4 theories: Jamies real mother is Johns sister. They'll tell you all the reasons why our way of life in Montana are bad for this country, bad for our future. Jamie still reminds John of his sister and the pain she caused the family so John maintains a bit of resentment. A fearless and free-spirited young woman, she meets and falls in love with Sam, but their love is cut short by tragedy. Margaret Dutton John Dutton (Kevin Costner) John was still alive when we last saw him at the end of the finale, even after taking a couple bullets and unable to call for help since his phone was damaged. A new theory has proposed Jamie Dutton (played by Wes Bentley) will uncover another game-changing secret about his hidden parentage in the next season of Yellowstone. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. Mary Abel (Emma Malouff) is Claire's last surviving child, until she too meets her demise in 1883. In the fourth episode of season 4, John explains that his mother took Peter's death to heart. During some of the most pivotal moments of the latest season, Jamie unearthed his birth records to discover ranch owner John Dutton (Kevin Costner) is not his biological father. Who was Evelyn Dutton's favorite child? In addition, the Duttons knew the Randalls, as they had known Phyllis before she married Garrett. He is one of at least three John's in the family, the others being his son, John Dutton Jr., and his grandson, John Dutton III. John Dutton's mother and father would never have another child, which means that unless there is another late brother or sister we've never heard of, John is an only child. However, Kevin Costners John Dutton is the Dutton familys present patriarch. From a recurring narrative perspective, Jamie keeps making rash decisions, based on emotion and limited information, that negatively impact the Dutton family. Jamie and Garett Randalls Relationship Movies. Garrett became overwhelmed with anger that Jamie was put in such a dangerous situation. However, the narrative does not touch upon Johns relationship with his mother. Read More: Does John Dutton Have Siblings? Her mother, so distraught by the loss of her child, ends her own life. The series frequently uses time jumps to slowly reveal more about the Duttons dark history, so Jamies biological mother could very well appear beyond the grave in season four. I lean more to the Dutton side than Evelyn but either are possible. Kevin Costner Says Yellowstones Beautiful Locale Hides The Regions Dark History, Yellowstone Confirms the Relationship Status of This Power Couple, Steve Burton Announces His Return Date: Finally, the Time Has Come!, Thats That, Then: General Hospitals Maurice Benard Reveals Sonnys One True Love. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. DON'T MISS:James May opens up on pretty long days filming Grand Tour[EXCLUSIVE]Virgin River season 3 spoilers: Lizzie and Ricky romance sealed[INSIGHT]Lucifer fans tip season 6 time jump after episode title clues[THEORY]. He is portrayed as a child by Audie Rick in 1883 and then as an adult by James Badge Dale in 1923. Lee Dutton was shot by Robert Long in Season 1 of 'Yellowstone.'. Yellowstone season 4's ending may not be as explosive as the finales of previous seasons, but it sets up what might be the show's best storylines yet. Jamies relationship with his family has always been rocky and learning that he was adopted only made things more complicated.